03-02-2009, 12:35 PM
Bismillah
Oo jazaki Allah khairan, got your point, actually in Arabic the article even reads totally different. In Arabic the title is women voice in impure and will make the wall <b>impure as </b>well (there is another word but cannt remember it now Sobhan Allah) rather than properly explaining how women voice is haram in terms of singing. True, but you know what? unfortunately, in Medina for instance, when I access Rawda sharifa, like 5 years ago, the system was not yet proper as now. Iranian and Shia women would wail in a loud voice, just next to the Messenger's salla Allah a`lyhee wa sallam and no one tells them off. I guess it is different now, they do stop them. Me too I was in the same situation and had to explain why a woman cannt lead Salat.
I will post something on that later Insh aAllah as I read there were marches and riots in medina last week.