A two part question

[submit]

Salam alaykum.

The problem usually stems when people become infatuated with their so called knowledge and analytical ability.

I'm not arrogant.

Good u quoted this Ayah the underlined part about the judgment is a direct command to follow the sunnah.

But i just explained that. He cannot judge our situation. Why? Because he is dead. However, there is a way he can judge. It's if our situation is almost identical to a situation explained in the Hadiths. But if our situation is just similar or not similar at all, then we cannot use his previous judgement.

How about this Ayah:


"And perform the prayer, and give Zakat and obey the Messenger (Muhammad) that you may receive mercy (from Allah)." (Quran 24:56)


If u follow quran, read carefull, in many positions Allah Say Obey Allah and the Messenger, but look at this Ayah. Because Allah Knew that there will be people like u submit who would come saying what u r saying, Allah Put this Ayah calling to obey the Messenger.

It's in present tense. I'd obey into death if i could. But he can't speak. Although i suppose he could contact me in a dream. I've heard of people meeting the prophets in their dreams...

And in the second bolded part, are u refering to the Messenger prayer and peace be upon him? watch it ok. U better be more respectful. Ok.

Yes i'm referring to the prophet Muhammed, peace and blessings upon him. I'm not being disrespectful. He was only a man. A great man. One of the best. But still only a man. I love him alot. But i love Allah more.


I did not mean to sound disrespectful, sister.


I'm just saying we should follow some Hadiths issued from a man, which means they are not eternal hadiths, rather than follow an eternal Qur'an from an Eternal Lord?


may Allah bless you.