Need clarification from CC.

[Curious Christian]

Bismillah:


:) You dont need to start a new website CC, you can simply invite your Christians friends over here to discuss and hear more views ;)


Yes i guess you didnt.


Ok, one of the brothers asked you <b>how do you understand the Trinity</b>. then you replied:


<i>"simple"</i>


<b>am a man</b>


am a father (father of my son)


am a son (son of my father)


then you concluded:


<b>i am three.</b>


so in response to the above answer i asked you "f you <b>AS A MAN </b> told your wife a secret, will YOU <b>AS A FATHER </b> and <b>AS A SON </b> know this secret as well?


means since you are the <b>same person </b> who is a <b>MAN</b>, and you are the <b>same person </b> who is <b>FATHER</b>, and you are the <b>same person </b> who is a <b>SON</b>, naturally you will know <b>ANYTHING</b> said by <b>YOURSELF. (man, father and son)</b>. you follow??


<b>will this example you give will perfectly match with Trinity ? Father, son and holy ghost????</b> is God the Father knew something that unknown to God the son and God the holy ghost?


ok another example, if you as a man died (may Allah give you long life till you accept Islam :) ) will you as father and son die also ??? naturally YES because you are <b>the same person.</b>


will this example match perfectly with trinity? father, son and holy ghost?


Salam


Wael.

My analogy wasn't perfect. But yes if I as a man told my wife a secret then I as a Father and as a Son would know the secret too.