Sept. 11

[Curious Christian]

On Sept. 11, 2001 a group of men boarded 4 planes with the intention of hijacking them and plowing them into the world trade center, the pentagon and the white house.


It was revealed that these men were are extremist Islamic terrorists from Osama Bin Laden's terror group "Al Queda."


These men thought that they were holy warriors in a jihad against the west. They, and many Muslims around the world, believe that these men are martyrs who are now enjoying paradise with the "dark eyes" (taken from the farawell videos from several of the attackers).


SO my question is this...Where do <b>YOU</b> think that these men are now? Do you believe that they are in Paradise?

[Muslimah]

Bismillah


salam CC


Matter of fact, this is a serious judgment that any Muslim is not supposed to make. We are not allowed to judge who will go where. All we can do, when a Muslim dies, is to invoke upon Allah to bestow mercy on the desceases and overlook his/her sins and faults. We are not allowed to interfer in Allah's Duty which is to destine people to either destination paradise or hell (i seek refuge to Allah from hell fire and the disgrace on the Day of Judgment).

[Curious Christian]

Bismillah


salam CC


Matter of fact, this is a serious judgment that any Muslim is not supposed to make. We are not allowed to judge who will go where. All we can do, when a Muslim dies, is to invoke upon Allah to bestow mercy on the desceases and overlook his/her sins and faults. We are not allowed to interfer in Allah's Duty which is to destine people to either destination paradise or hell (i seek refuge to Allah from hell fire and the disgrace on the Day of Judgment).

Fair enough Muslimah...let me re-phrase.


Do you think that it is wrong that some evil men convince other men and women to blow themselves up in the name of Allah and promise them paradise? These "recruits" are convinced that they will inherit Paradise by their act. IS that wrong?

[Dan]

Bismillah


Here are some scholarly replies:


http://www.fatwa-online.com/worship/jiha.../index.htm

[Kal]

I still question the accuracy of the 'official' report. And i do not question because it involves further Muslims.

Fair enough Muslimah...let me re-phrase.


Do you think that it is wrong that some evil men convince other men and women to blow themselves up in the name of Allah and promise them paradise? These "recruits" are convinced that they will inherit Paradise by their act. IS that wrong?

You dont even need to be a person of the faith in question, to be able to answer this and im frankly offended. You seem to be fishing for some common ground with people here - do not use pathetic dressings to your questions, and you might get the reply you want.


This isn't a courtroom.