What do you guys think of this?

[radiyah]

because Allah Knows best we can not assign ourselves judges and label who is a true Muslim and who is not. I really fear much going into this area, many factors must be taken in consideration and we must never really let our feelings towards Islam take us in this direction.

Sister Muslimah is right, I was hasty in answering this and mistaken, and I am not to judge who is true muslim or not only Allah knows best and only Allah knows what is in the hearts of his slaves. May Allah forgive me for this. I do not know what is your purpose here Hazam bro. and sister Muslimah if u wish to close this thread do close it I totally agree with u, especially if Hazam's bro insists that everybody on this board to answer his question. May Allah forgive me for my ignorance.

Allah knows best

[Hazam'sBro]

Do you care because you are a spy? :confused:

Yes, I am an unemployed spy who spends countless hours on an anonymous message board while studying for medical school boards :thumup:

[naseeha]

hey every body dont be sarcastic over deen's concern... this is legitimate...

I am not saying that hazam is a spy hahah...

but we need to enquire into these things... I live on a tiny caribbean island.. and one of my close freinds once encountered CIA spies who were pretending to be his freinds... it this happens offline where we can see everything... it is more likely to happen online where the spies have the luxury of anonymity... so dont be sarcastic....

any one of us can be spies... in order to guard ourselves from this all that we need to do is to stick with quraan and sunnah... everythin will be ok

[Muslimah]

<blockquote data-ipsquote="" class="ipsQuote" data-ipsquote-username="Muslimah" data-cite="Muslimah" data-ipsquote-contentapp="forums" data-ipsquote-contenttype="forums" data-ipsquote-contentid="1524" data-ipsquote-contentclass="forums_Topic"><div>Hazam, originally u stated your position as agnostic, in other words, not sure about Allah's existence. <b>why r u coming now trying to judge Muslims? Judging them according to what? if u try to judge Muslims by Islam, then u imply that Islam is true????????????????????????????
</b>
Other wise, why would u care? I know the thread is closed, Radiyah after your permission I will open it for Hazam to reply to this point???? and then lock it again is it ok with u??? sorry for that hope u dont mind :embarrase

I care, because I need to know if people actually support bin ladens cause or not.

</div></blockquote>

Hazam I think u r quite aware of my point, I will try to rephrase it.


U r asking us Muslims if we think of Usama as true Muslim. Well of course in our judgement we will be <b>using Islam as criteria, right</b>?? So in this case the <b>criteria we are using is not approved by u</b> if I am not mistaken u r doubting Allah's existence and having trouble accepting religions in general.


So why do u care to get an opinion based on invalid criteria (according to u)?


I think the point is clear


waiting for your reply

[Dan]

Yes, I am an unemployed spy who spends countless hours on an anonymous message board while studying for medical school boards :thumup:

Bismillah


I knew it!! You medical school guys are so fishy. I can see you right now sitting at your computer with your satellite uplink pointing to the sky, computer in a briefcase, ready to run at a moments notice. The sunglasses do not hide you from us, buddy.


Btw Do all spies have to wear tuxedos all the time? I ask because I look good in a suit and might get into the spy game for the cool clothes.


Peace, 00H

[Muslimah]

Dan Mash a Allah your sense of humor really gets me out of many hard situations


Jazakum Allah khairan