06-08-2004, 12:36 PM
as salam alykom sister Lulu
very well put, that is why I made a question to the poster of the question to which I never got a reply.
well before closing this thread as Lulu suggested, if u care about an Islamic response which we put in many other threads:
1. no one is allowed to judge another Muslim as being true Muslim or not.
2. Even a murderer we can not say this one is going to Hell, this is Allah's domain to say who is going where.
3. A Muslim is judged by his intention, according to this no one knows what is in the heart of any one, even one who embraces Islam for reasons that looks like not sincere, still we can not judge.
4. A Muslim who falls into this problem of judging others is in serious trouble with Allah.
5. A specific factor about Usama in particular, people tend to judge him with what he said or did, who can cofirm that he said or did what is being probagated.
Now having this said.
Thread is closed