04-23-2004, 11:30 AM
Quote:<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b>jihad in palestine is halal, & it is a must, & we are to help them with whatever we can. Now as for killing children & women along with others, we know this is not allowed in Islam, but still we are not to judge that & say that they are terrorists & they are going to hell.</b>if we are not to judge them to hell, how did we seem to judge them to heaven?
plus you know very well killing children & women is not allowed. unjust murder is a big sin. but still you make it seem right for ppl to do unjust murder in the name of Allah? isn't that telling a lie about Allah? making Allah as an excuse to do unjust murder? isn't that simply wrong? i do agree with you that we don't know the fate of the suicide bombers - it's in Allah's Hands. true... but saying unjust killing is acceptable is NOT right. i think its making a <i>haram</i> a <i>halal</i>.
Quote:<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b>Reliable scholars have unanimously agreed that Palestinians who participate in the current Intifada are sincere and true Muslims, and that their Jihad is in the Cause of Allah.</b>when done according to Rasulullah SAW's way - Jihad is true. but have you heard Rasulullah SAW sending teenagers to do suicide bombings to the Quraisy? did he told people to slay every Quraisy that stand in muslims way - women & children, young & old -- that every Quraisy must pay for hurting muslims? never.
when Bilal bin Rabah was tortured, Abu Bakr didn't slay the torturer. he peacefully bought Bilal & he became the first mua'zzin. when they wanna kill Rasulullah SAW, he moved to Medina & built an islamic country. that's a better way to survive, isn't it?
Quote:<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b>A person who blows himself up sacrifices his life for the survival of others. </b>& also death of thers. also isn't suicide a crime that removes ones faith in Allah? apart from the unjust murder to the innocents? bombs are blind. it might kill muslims & believers too. it might even kill your own mom, dad etc...
Quote:<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b>Allah says in the Glorious Qura'n: \"And spend of your substance in the cause of Allah, and make not your own hands contribute to (your) destruction; but do good; for Allah loveth those who do good.\" (Al-Baqara:195).</b>exactly, you're brilliant... <b>make not your hands contribute to destruction</b> and <b>do good</b>. the thought is right... but the question is, is the action right? imagine, if i kill my baby so that she will go to heaven, is that good? am i not a bad mother? won't i go to heaven? the thought is good, but the way it is done... is it right?