11-25-2003, 11:11 AM
as salam alykom
let me step here for a moment.
Now just to try and settly things, brother Abu, scholars differed about the status of 11/9 whether or not it is jihad to start with, most importantly is the hot debate about the truth behind who did it. So I prefer that we simply dont brag about it or take pride in it. Using your same quotes that women and children will be only killed if mixed among a fighting army or by mistake makes it in total violation of jihad rules. Abu, no muslim is unaware of what is happening to muslims, and Purgetroy, we have rules regarding who to love or befreinds with and who are not.
Abu we all know the situation of muslims around the world and it is just making the Quran and hadeeth proven correct nothing more.
again as for Jihad, we can not just call any act as jihad out of enthusiam.
Purgetroy, martyrdom bombins also received much attention from scholars with difference of opinions about its legitimacy.
see girls are doing in it in Palestine and scholars studied it giving different fatwas between martyrdom or suicide.
See things which are like this are better just left for the judgement of Allah
We are simply encouraged not to judge.