11-24-2003, 11:43 AM
Sa'ab bin Jathamah (may Allah be pleased with him) reported from that the Prophet was asked about the people in the homes of Mushrikun (Polytheist) when they are attacked at night and their women and children are affected, he said: "they are part of them".
Can you comment on the above hadeeth????
So, this Hadith shows that women, children and all those the killing of whom is forbidden, when they are separate, it is permissible to kill them when they are mixed up with the fighters and it is not possible to separate. This is because they had asked the Prophet about the case which is "attacking at night", in which case it is not possible to differentiate, and he permitted them because "things may be allowed when they occur along the way but be forbidden when separate".
Ibn Hazm, commenting on the Hadith that "Banu Quraidah were paraded before the Prophet, and he ordered the killing of all those who had attained puberty", said: "this is a general ruling from the Prophet, since he did not leave out an old man, a merchant, a farmer or any other person; this was related from him with genuine Ijmaa' (Al-Muhallaa vol. 6 p. 299)
Which modern age sheikhs have i quoted from that you dont agree with???
You said you only found 3 decent sheikhs, why was this? Or maybe you want scholars to give fatwas out that agree with your desires???? Like that fool who said democracy, music, riba etc etc are Halaal......You would be suprised to see have many 'muslims' search for 'scholars' that will give fatwahs so they could do haraam stuff.