Mohammad, prophet or cult leader ?

[Guest]

<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b>Al salam 3ala man itaba3 alhoda.</b>

 Well  HabibHibee, what kind of input are you searching for particularily, are you seeking for the truth, or you just want to show in any way or another that prophet Mohammad is not a prophet  and he is not devine, and also you are saying that other prophets are not devine (then you are not a beleiver of anything:confused: ). (I think I must also defend other prophets from misinterpretating their history )

Just a general feedback is fine radiyah. Looking at how Mohammad received a lot of Allahs revelations seems to me to require a certain leap of faith. After all, a lot of the "revelations" were dreams were they not ? Nothing divine in that I would argue.

<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b></b>

 And about  me being relegious, yes I am,  

Good for you, nothing wrong with that.

<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b> But still I have a mind that makes me think that how can buddist and hindus worship Idols that men sculptured and animals :confused:  that are created b by God, or how can there be 2 Gods.  </b>

I don't understand it either, but then again, why would anyone follow something as equally dubious as a prophet (any one of them) who have revelations only revealed to them. Funny old world, aint it ?

<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b>so tell me what kind of input you want and I will gladly answer,  If I got lost somewhere and couldn't find the answer for you I will gladly ask the scholar  who is teaching us. </b>

Hey that's very kind of you. I will take you up on that. Can I do it via PM or should I post ? I don't have anything specific right now but I have some stuff coming up.

<i>Originally posted by radiyah </i><b></b>

Really it hearts me when I c you like this not knowing the truth, I wish to help you if you are willing, so I am waiting for your answer:rolleyes:  

As I told you before we dont force any1 here we try to convince you, if we succeeded it is by aid of Allah Allmighty,

if not then it is our fault and mistake.

 Sub7an Allah wa Allhamdullilah Wala7awla wala Gowata illa Billah

your concern is very touching but don't worry about me. If the truth is out there, here's hoping it reaches me.

But really though I can sort of see being a muslim when born into it but it's marketability as a mainstream religion to non muslims just looks iffy. Particulalry the central character in all of this, Mohammad. Have you read much about his history and the history of his time. Deary me.