01-20-2009, 04:42 PM
We are all responsible for our own actions, yet we are commanded in the Quran to practice amr bil ma'roof and nahy anil munkar ie enjoining the right and forbidding the wrong. Hence my challenging the implications of the article you posted.
I dont think my points were addressed at all by the way in the article you posted. For example where does the article deal with the fact that the Quran never existed in a book form during the Prophets time, hence the Sunnah is not applicable to this case?
Instinct is a subjective experience, my instinct is completely opposite in that it is right. I do believe that anything posted on a public forum is subject to scrutiny and challenge.