Bismillah
Quote:Ok its been a while so forgive me if im not up to speed with everything.
In His Name the Most High
However In Shi'i narrations there is mention of certain merits of visiting the shrine of Lady Fatima Ma'suma in Qom,
From Bihar al-Anwar by Allama Majlisi
<b>وَسَتُدْفَنُ فيها امْرَأةٌ مِنْ اَوْلادى تُسَمّى فاطِمَةَ، فَمَنْ زارَها وَجَبَتْ لَهُ الجنّة</b>
“A lady from my children, by the name of Fatima will be buried in Qum. Whoever visits her [shrine], will certainly be admitted to Heaven.”
Please note that the Arabic version of the hadeeth does not contain any reference to Qum. Just as the hadeeth included in Ibn Katheer that you didnt comment on. The one regarding the dust of Karbala. That is if the hadeeth is correct. Sobhan Allah, the language of the hadeeth is really very obviously made up. This is not the language style of our beloved teacher and Messenger salla Allah a`lyhee wa sallam. Here you are refering to Fatima Bint Mussa may Allah be pleased with all of them ?? correct???? Can you also tell me who is the narrator. I mean a chain of narrators is not included in this hadeeth.
Sorry to say Karbala, but I really observed from your valuable input here, I mean on the personal level, how the Shia school is founded on a set of Quran interpretations, hadeeth ..etc put together for political reasons.