Ask a Shia

[Karbala]

Ok its been a while so forgive me if im not up to speed with everything.


In His Name the Most High

BTW, since you are calling yourself follower of Ahull Bayt, did Ali Radiyah Allah u an`hu or any of his descendants practice Muta, I know none of them?????????

Hmm interesting question, I actually don't know the answer to it. Give me a while ill find out. Ps even if they never practiced Muta doesnt make Muta haram, there are traditions narrated from the very same people establishing the permissiblity of Muta. Sort of like none of them practiced divorce but that doesn't make divorce haram.

Where in Sunnah of Ahul Bayt that you go to visit Qum before leaving for Haj, or Karbala, although I gave you the correct text of the Hadeeth, you still insist on its sacrdness. Any way, where in Sunnah that you do this?

I think you have it all wrong. It isnt a sunnah to go to qum before or after hajj. People simply do it because logistically it is easier when you've taken time off work and already have connecting flights too and from Makkah. Personally i went to Qom outside the Hajj season. It really has nothing to do with hajj.

Where are the hadeeth that establishes an advantage of Qum???? or make it necessary to visit before or after Haj???

However In Shi'i narrations there is mention of certain merits of visiting the shrine of Lady Fatima Ma'suma in Qom,


From Bihar al-Anwar by Allama Majlisi


وَسَتُدْفَنُ فيها امْرَأةٌ مِنْ اَوْلادى تُسَمّى فاطِمَةَ، فَمَنْ زارَها وَجَبَتْ لَهُ الجنّة


“A lady from my children, by the name of Fatima will be buried in Qum. Whoever visits her [shrine], will certainly be admitted to Heaven.”