Ask a Shia

[Karbala]

Seems I will just make an intervention here, Karbala, most of the time when i pray in Ka`ba and note I say most of the time, Iranian women actually break the line by not joining us.

We have discussed this before. I dont know what you saw. But Last year at Hajj I was with an iranian group and we had direct orders from the Supreme Leader if Iran and also other Marja's to pray in Jama'a and not on our own.

they keep approching me either in Masjed Nabawi or Ka`ba and insist I join them in a special dua

It seems like they were reciting Dua Tawassul. We have discussed Tawassul before.

Now I know we did discuss Torbah before, as I understand this torbah, I m not discussing the sharia reasons behind it as u presented, but it has to be brought from Karbala, being called Torbah Husayniah makes it a condition to be obtained from there, am I not correct???

No, it doesnt have to be brought from Karbala. Any earth will do. But most Turbahs are actually made in Karbala. But it isnt essential.