Bismillah
Karbala, u seem to be a thoughful person, but sometimes u really confuse me. Originally, the whole shia approach is based on a number of hadeeth like that of Shia to Ali, like that of Al kisaa..etc. Those are foundations of shia faith. Then u want to tell me that you pick and choose from what suits the orientation. How do u feel about all this, is this logical enough....
scrutiny since they come from fallible sources.
a Syed ie. a descendant of the Prophet of Mercy(saw) through his daughter AlZahra
And this is exactly what I was trying to refer to on the other thread, when I asked u how u all as shia perceive those who are Shareef, or Sada? seems u do put much weight on them as iindividuals.
Sobhan Allah, there is much contradiciton that u are unable to see karbala or shall I say u tend to ignore the point when raised.