07-17-2007, 01:46 PM
Salam sister
So what verse(s) in the Quran support the traditionists allegation to kill the apostates?
The stories of killing the apostates who were involved in acts opposing the religion during the time of the prophet hold no water to support your allegation, those killed by the prophet (if true) were not dealt with as apostates, rather (ENEMIES OF THE RELIGION WHO WERE MISLEADING OTHERS AND PROMOTING LIES ABOUT IT TO WEAKEN IT), i.e. they must be faught and killed because they want to hurt us based on the account of our religion to kill that religion and prevent the message of Allah from spreading to others.
The Quran also contradicts your allegation that this punishment was forced because Allah don't accept those who take the religion lightly, please sister, don't say things about Allah that you have no authority, this is a great sin in the Quran, The Quran clearly talked about the apostates and even talked about them being belivers then disbelieve then believe then increase in disbelief, how lightly those people menioned in the Quran were taking their religion? (YET IT NEVER SAID THAT WE SHOULD PUNISH THEM RATHER THEIR FATE IS WITH ALLAH)
I'm really puzzled that an intlligent woman like you follows that human non sense and lies about Allah and yet you do your best to justify it using human stories instead of Allah words in the Quran
Can you please dear sister support your allegation from the Quran using Allah words especially when it comes to killing people
Salam