Ask a Shia

[Karbala]

Salam,

Why don't you just do what you normally do and use a dictionary? Do you consider Ni'matallah Aljaza'iri, Al Majlisi, Al Qummi, Al Khoie, and Al Kulaini as non-muslims...?

OK but it may take a while. It would just be easier for me if someone translated into english. These scholars are all highly acclaimed by Shia. You see I am a bit suspicious about Al-Khoei ever doubting the perfect arrangement of the Quran or quoting opinions from Al- Kulaini and Al-Majlisi or Al-Qummi. The reason for this is that he has written a whole book confirming the authenticity of the Quran in its present form http://al-islam.org/tahrif_quran/


There are traditions of Tahreef from people Like Al-Kulaini and Al-Majlisi. But these arent the opinions of the authors but simply included for comprehensiveness. Nevertheless I will read the link you gave me. It may take me a while but Inshallah Ill get there.


Muslimah:


Thanks for the link. It may take me a while to read it but inshallah ill get there. I read your post 148 and you are right in everything you say. I interpret the quran according to the best of my ability just like you do. If there is one thing we can perhaps agree on is that Shia and Sunni both deserve to respect each other as muslims and not get into the takfeeri mess that has plagued the Ummah. We are all lovers of Allah and His final Messenger the best of creations Mohammad(saw).