Quote:Well, I should stop because usually I use my brain and I explained to you from a native Arabic speaker viewpoint, which I verified with Tafseer of Shaarawi (if u have heard about him), besides being a prominent scholar, he is an excellent one in the Arabic language, the part of 33:33 has nothing to do with calling Fatma and her household as ma`soum Karbala.
It is true you are a native arabic speaker and I am not. What more can I do? I consulted arabic grammar books, dictionaries and other arabic native speakers as well as numerous examples in the Quran. I can either believe you or I can believe my own research. What do you suggest I do? I have not heard of Tafsir of Shaarawi. I do not blindly follow scholars. Tell me WHY you think Shaarawi is right? What are his REASONS?
33:33 has everything to do with Fatima and her household as Ma'soom as hadith Al-Kisa proves.
Quote:I m still on my position Karbala, but the problem is that u dont want to see this side, since it really serves as basic foundation.
Just because I don't agree with your position does not mean that there is a problem.