07-13-2007, 01:28 PM
Bismillah
No my question regarding Zainab's name is not strange Karbala, I intended to draw your attention that Fatima named her after Zainab Al Kobra.
Sobhan Allah, this whole story of Ahul bayt is just crafted in a way to have Fatma's household as ma`soum and so are the anticipated Imam.
Well, I should stop because usually I use my brain and I explained to you from a native Arabic speaker viewpoint, which I verified with Tafseer of Shaarawi (if u have heard about him), besides being a prominent scholar, he is an excellent one in the Arabic language, the part of 33:33 has nothing to do with calling Fatma and her household as ma`soum Karbala. Certainly u are aware that part of Quran's miracle and evidence that no one can distort it is the very rich arabic grammer it uses.
Well, for the sake of leaving argument as commanded by our teacher, Messenger and leader, I m still on my position Karbala, but the problem is that u dont want to see this side, since it really serves as basic foundation. Brother, the Ayahs has nothing to do with strictly calling Fatima and household ma`soum, neither does it execule the wives, nor fatma is the only daughter. Re read some of the hadeeth talking about how the daughters were divorced except for Zainab who was married to Al A`as....
Well, we shall continue conversing though brother.