Ask a Shia

[Karbala]

Shia's affirm that there is no God except Allah and Muhammad is his prophet.

Ahsantum Brother JazakumAllah Khair.

khumaini.... is not all Shia, and not all Shia are Khumaini

Ayatollah Ruhollah Al-Musawi Al-Khumaini (May God have mercy on him) is perhaps one of the most celebrated scholars of the modern era for Shia. His statements can be taken as representative of the School of Ahlulbayt. Im not sure why you are trying to separate him from the Shia maybe its because of some of the things abdulwalee said.

I told him these statements can be found in the Shaytan Khomeini's book: 'Hukmutal Islaamiyah'

There is no book by that name. I think he meant hukoomat al-islamiyah which has a very different meaning. I have read the book and there is very little Aqeedah mentioned in the book. Its a book on governance. Abdulwalee and people like him have a clever way of fooling people. If you notice I provide complete references and in most cases website links for the reader to verify what I have stated. But Abdulwalee as you may have noticed either doesnt provide references or when he does he either lies or deliberately doesnt mention where in the source so he can twist things out of context. I suspect he probably just copies and pastes things from random websites that he finds.