Bismillah
as salam alykom
sorry Wael, it seems that I got u wrong when u said that u agree with Suhail's opinion which included and stressed banning him. Although I shouldnt get u wrong on this specially, to tell u the truth i was suprised.
Well, I m sure u know what I meant when I said that we should not expect them to respect the Messenger salla Allah a`lyhee wa sallam. IN this I m talking about a general condition, not exceptions. Of course there is also this book that rated him among top or even first (not sure) best men who had an impact on humanity.
When I made this comment I meant the general condition. I m sure u know what I mean.
Alhamdulelah, that we are able to discuss and explain more and even use the situation to show that Quran includes what CC and the like are saying.
And I agree with Nasra about this:
Reminds me of Abu Bakr, Uthman, Umar Ibn Al-Khatab, Khalid Ibn Walid.
True this is very true.
Sobhan Allah