Bismillah
If uttering things against Islam automatically got people kicked off then JD would have been gone (and stayed gone) by now.
I love the Prophet, period. I hate to see him disrespected. My blood boiled at the words CC wrote but... if the Prophet can have refuse piled in front of his door, have animal guts thrown on him, be choked, beated, watch those he loved beaten and abused, we can IN THE FULL INTEREST OF DAWAH keep calling to those who abuse our Prophet.
I appreciate the approach that Nasra took and Muslimah. CC even said it... he does not like Jesus being abused either. Maybe he feels "safe" to make such comments bc he knows we would never "retaliate" by slandering the one whom he holds dear bc we also hold him dear.
To sum it up... I HATE our Prophet being slandered... no question. If one could see how my jaw tightened, but then I remember what our Prophet would do In the name of Dawah.
I forget who was abusing him but Our Rasool and Abu Bakr were sitting together and this woman came up and started abusing Abu Bakr, calling him all kinds of nasty things. Abu Bakr took it patiently. The woman then started abusing the Prophet. Abu Bakr jumped up and started defending Muhammad (saws) and got very angry. The Prophet got up to leave. Abu Bakr asked where he was going. The Prophet said that the angels were hanging around when Abu Bakr was showing patience but when he got angry they left and the Prophet does not hang out where there are no angels. (Did the Prophet get mad when he was being lambasted by this women?)
Insha'Allah I have not offended anyone... If I have please forgive me. Astaghfirullah
As Salam alaikum wa rahmatullahi wa barakatu