08-18-2006, 04:57 PM
Bismillah
Dear Suhail I add to my sister M here, he is a well known scholar, and u r accusing him bad accusations which u r not sure of. many scholars differ and many scholars give various fatwas, we may agree or differ with them, but for sure they have more knowledge than us, they might be right or wrong is not for us to say unless we are sure of it. Non muslims who make muftis and judge us or muslim scholars are just adding more to their ignorance. Suhail, u should know that non muslims do not read everything in islam, they just take little of it and judge upon it. And John Mash'Allah he is one of a scholar, he reads every bit of an informative post we put for him, he is always bored have no time, and so on... then he says he knows everything, really :rolleyes: . Scholars are human beings, they make mistakes, but that does not mean that u attack him that way. reconsider that kind of description suhail, and do not put yourself in a position that u will be asked by Allah(SWT) why u said such words about a muslim scholar.
Allah knows best, alhamdulilah for the blessings of Islam.
Salam