01-21-2006, 01:38 PM
Bismillah
as salam alykom Radiyah
After re reading your reply, of course Allah's Will was the reason for springing out Zamzam, but cocurrently it was a response to the dua of Hajar who was in the state of the compelled and destressed. I understand that sometimes scholars are concerned for people's misunderstanding of the happening of miracles that it might be ascribed to human beings. But we also have to be clear how dua is effective and how Allah Promised to grant the compelled and destressed the dua when made.
So just felt I should clarify this point.