Abrogation

[Anyabwile]

So, from a theological standpoint, it is not valid to just ignore this hadith or say that it is not authentic.  If the Bukhari collection is considered to be authentic, then all the hadith in Bukhari must be considered to be authentic.  And, if this hadith is authentic, then it must be explained.

Yes although i know muslims who have a system of filtering out genuine hadith that don't sound like they fit with the Prophets character or they are embaressed of. Some have said to me "if it doesnt sound like the Prophet would have done that then i ignore it" some Muslims i prayed with and follow Islam in every way have said this to me. However my Imam said to me once if it's in authentic Hadith we must belive it. At least he was honest.


But yes, some Muslims do filter out if it doesnt sound right. It's like when you hear Muslims denying that Aisha was 6 yrs old when The Prophet Mohammed married her or showed intrest in marrying her and 9yrs old when he had sex with her. Some will say 19 or 16. Despite authentic Hadith confirming Her age, not to mention Aisha herself etc etc. But that's not really arguable in the Muslim world now, more the few embaressed converts who try to deny this.


I wish i was wise btw looking back i'd say foolish. But thank you.