Quote: it is possible that Angel Gibraeel was right there with the Prophet Muhammad when this happened, and he gave the Prophet the correct words by the Order of Allah.
But then this would be Allah correcting a mistake?? and Allah knowing the future would not need to correct a mistake or something he'd forgot to mention. Allah words are pefect and need no changing, am i right?
Also these (Bukhari) Hadith are where some of the most important aspects of the religion are learnt from. The ONLY place how to pray etc etc would be learnt from.
To pick whats fabricated and what isn't from the two authentic hadith is just blind fear of not wanting to accept some of the more questionable things Mohammed did Moshie.
One of the many things i admired about Muslimah (even tho now disagree with her) was how she wasnt ashamed of the genuine hadith and stuck by them. Same with the quran, one time (and forgive me if im wrong Muslimah i might be [img]style_emoticons/default/tongue.gif[/img] ) but one time on here we were talking about space and i mentioned the stars and you actually said, they were there to ward of Jin. You didnt try and say oh thats a mis interpritation, i know thats from Quran but its the same example of not being ashamed of the more unusual and distrubing aspects of Islam. You "stick by your guns" as we say in the uk.
You cant call a reliable hadith un authentic because you dont like it, that makes it sound like one is scared or embaressed of things the prophet has done.