09-10-2005, 10:52 AM
Bismillah
as salam alykom
Jazakum Allah khairan for posting this hadeeth I was looking for it for a long time.
Brother to actually sum this up.
May be Suail, you and me are all talking the same language saying the same things but in different styles.
The only thing, out of fear of judging just as u exactly quoted now, is I prefer not to generalize or confirm that the Ayah applies on those men. After all those are brothers in Islam and to say that they are among those who would say we believe while they dont till the end of the Ayahs. Now this is a grave accusation when we point it at a certain person. If the description does not fit the person it returns on one who accused.
And just as u exactly brought in the hadeeth about the man who interefered in Allah's domain of judging people, this would be making a definit judgment about a person.
Let us just say that we make dua for our brothers to be guided to the correct path, so that they know how to implement Jihad, when and where to launch Qital.
we dont wish for ourselves to be judged this hard so we should not also wish it for our fellow Muslims.