09-08-2005, 07:52 PM
Bismillah
as salam alykom brother Ahmed
Welcome to the board and jazakum Allah khairan on your first post.
Well the idea is worth considering and re reading, true the Quran calls the hypocrites as hypocrites. I just have one reservation about the laden part.
Brother it is much better for all of us as muslims to never judge any other Muslim who engaged in Jihad. Yes the apparent may be violating what we know. But they are the Mujaheddeen and we are the sitting. Of course u know what i am referring to in the Ayah that says; not equal those who do jihad and those who are sitting.
Plus I fully agree with u that beheading is not justified, but that is if it was done by Muslims to start with. So is the blowing up, unless it is in Palestine or other hot Muslim areas which can be clearly defined as battle field. Then we are allowed to fight and deter the enemy who is envading. Again I stress this who is envading.
Not to consider a place like Egypt a hot area and start terrorising innoncents. Yet this is also explained thru a hadeeth.
To cut it short, i do like your logic here Mash a Allah.
True they feel that they are doing good while it is the contrary la hawal wala qowata ilah billah
We are looking forward to more contribution on your part brother.