08-14-2005, 01:09 PM
Muslimah asked:
> U r quoting from the Quran and taking it an
> evidence for the establishment of Israel being
> a fulfillment of Allah's word, does this mean
> u admit the Quran is Allah's word???
Parts of the Koran (such as the prediction that the Jews will return to Israel) are in agreement with the bible. I agree with those parts of the Koran which are in agreement with the bible.
Rock asked:
> Last point,you mention the Israelian state
> established in 1947,can I understand that
> you consider the rest of palestine (about
> 50% of palestine) are occupied and the
> jew must return to 1947 border, I accept
> this as a start
Four times now, Arabs have started wars with Israel. And four times, the Arabs have lost the war and lost land in the process. Immediately after each war, the Arab nations have demanded the return of all land that they lost. Sorry, that's not the way things work.
If Israel had lost one of the wars, and after the war the Israelies had demanded the return of the border to the pre-war state, do you think the Arab nations would have agreed to this demand???
Israel has returned much of the land they captured (for example, the entire Sinai; the Gaza Strip which will be returned in a couple of weeks), but the decision to return the land is their decision alone. If the Arab nations wish to stop losing land, then they should stop declaring war on Israel.
I don't think we will ever see a return to the 1947 border. But I think we will eventually see a return to the 1949 border (which would mostly involve the return of the West Bank to Jordan).
Radiyah wrote:
> reepi stop translating The Quran to what u wish
Many Muslim scholars agree with me. For example, check out some of the writings of Shaykh Prof. Abdul Hadi Palazzi:
Italian Muslim cleric defends Israel
Eternal capital of the Jews, a Muslim viewpoint