why we will not take what rashad khalifa is saying

[Muslimah]

Bismillah


as salam alykom


Jazaki Allah khairan Radiyah for this post Mash a Allah


but why specially Ali, the forumula of Salat includes his companions as we say which covers more than Ali, or do u mean because he is one of the people of his house?


BTW, when I quoted Rashad, he was not referring to the prayers on the Messenger as the prayers, as I quoted him above, he translated it as supporting. He said Allah and the angles support him, and that is why he argued on how can we support him when he is dead.


But Alhamdulelah the whole Ayah is fully clear