02-03-2005, 09:45 PM
Bismillah
Peace ronniv and welcome back
I just skimmed thru Umm's replies so if u see any repetion pls forgive me
<b>Why, then, would some people become so upset at hearing the Quran recited in different ways if all it was was a different dialect and if they KNEW that the Quran was being revealed in this way?</b>Nobody gets upset for listening to different recitations matter of fact ways of recitation is a science on its own. Those who are advantaged with memorizing whole Quran and recite it on a pro basis, on an advanced stage of their learning they learn and use the 7 recitations.
<b>b ) What gave Uthman the right and the gall and the authority to DESTROY these other versions, or types, later on if they were truly revealed by Allah? This means that this man destroyed the very revelation of God!!! That baffles me that a person would do that if they TRULY believed it was God who did this?</b>
<b>This question is answered in the numerous articles I gave u. If u not satisfied with the replies then no problem u may just get over it. Like a student in a math class who can not understand a certain point regardless of the number of times it is explained to him/her, we are not trying to force u to understand or believe we merely give the reply.
</b>
c<b> ) It seems to me to be such a waste. Instead of clearing up things like what really happened to Jesus, for example, time is wasted in revealing the Quran in all these different Arabic "dialects", as they are called. </b>
<b>Nothing in Quran is a waste. And what really happened to Essa is clearly explained. Alla's Wisdom is not a waste. U too be careful with what u say about Allah we consider this a slander to Allah. But since it is your first time I will not ban u. Your measuring what should be and what should not be included in Quran. Who r u to do that??????
</b>
d<b> ) Furthermore, why reveal them in all these ways if Allah knew that they would all just be destroyed within a few years anyway?</b>
<b>Because Allah Wanted to.
</b>
<b>e ) Also, would it not have been more useful to maybe reveal the Quran in OTHER languages altogether as opposed to 14 different Arabic versions? Perhaps there wouldn't be so much difficulty with translation of it if Allah had simply given it in different LANGUAGES to begin with. But 7 or 14 different versions of Arabic??? I just don't get the point.</b>
You r repeating yourself here and stating that u can not understand but again trying to suggest what Allah Must do. Again be careful.
I might be repeating myself here ronniv.
see we are fine as Muslims, we are sure Allah Is One with no sons in any form either by title or actual. He Is Not consisting of parts, He Is Eternal, He Sent many prophets and Messengers to call for Islam and only Islam. He Sent Mohamed as the final Messenger as a last chance for mankind to believe, revealed Quran in Arabic as final book not changed or corrupted Alhamdulelah well preserved till the Day After.
We are fine like that we are not trying to bring u over to Islam, u can continue being with us of course.