Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Earth Quake In UK
#11

Quote:What is it with muslims and their love of despots?

A despot by definition cannot be loved. You seem to be contradicting yourself. Khomeini according to Ms. Fallaci herself was loved "too much".

Reply
#12
Quote:despot
/despot/


• noun a ruler with absolute power, <b>especially one who exercises it in a cruel or oppressive way.</b>


— DERIVATIVES despotic adjective despotism noun.


— ORIGIN Greek despotes ‘master, absolute ruler’.
Reply
#13

Quote:And hated by many.

Gandhi, Mandela, Churchill etc were also hated by many. The truth hurts sometimes, envy and jealousy are destructive emotions.

Reply
#14

Quote:Khomeini was despot that quickly turned on the very people that helped get the islamic revolution going and killing them in their thousands. Students, communists, political opponents were all fair game for Khomeini. I'm sure you are aware if this Karbala and I am also sure you would be perfectly fine with it.

Your perspective on history is predictable, very shallow. It wasn't Khomeini who turned on certain people, it was certain people who turned on Khomeini. You see Iraq right now? It was even worse in Iran post revolution, bombs going off everywhere, Saddam just invaded, rebellion etc etc, if it wasnt for the firmness of Khomeini in dealing with treachery iran would be much like todays Iraq. People were tried fairly and justice was served.

Reply
#15

Quote:Just a tiny example of Khomeini's "justice"
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988_execut..._prisoners


Just another tyrant in a long list of tyrants embraced by the religious fanatics like yourself karbala.

Hahahahaha, have you seen that wikipedia article? Lets go through its riculousness one by one.




Quote:Estimates of the number executed vary from 1,400 [4] to 30,000.[5][6]

1400 - 30000? that just shows how some people have tried to distort the history. Numbers cannot vary that badly withour raising eyebrows.




Quote:Great care was taken to keep the killings secret, and the government of Iran denies their having taken place

Wrong! The executions are openly admitted, infact you can find references of them in books like "The Narrative of Awakening" which is a Government sanctioned book!




Quote:it was in retaliation for the 1988 attack on the western borders of Iran by the PMOI, although this happened after the executions had begun

PMOI rebellion (siding with Saddam) happened after the executions begun?????


Unfortunately the author of this esteemed article shoots him/heself in the foot by providing the chronology of events, in which the executions happen AFTER the PMOI siding with Saddam.




Quote:Shortly before the executions commenced, Iranian leader Ayatollah Khomeini issued "a secret but extraordinary order - some suspect a formal fatwa." This set up "Special Commissions with instructions to execute members of People's Mojahedin Organization of Iran as moharebs (those who war against God) and leftists as mortads (apostates from Islam)." [8]
In part the letter read:


«از آنجا که منافقین خائن به هیچ وجه به اسلام معتقد نبوده و هر چه میگویند از روی حیله و نفاق آنهاست و به اقرار سران آنها از اسلام ارتداد پیدا کردهاند، با توجه به محارب بودن آنها و جنگ کلاسیک آنها در شمال و غرب و جنوب کشور با همکاریهای حزب بعث عراق و نیز جاسوسی آنها برای صدام علیه ملت مسلمان ما و با توجه به ارتباط آنان با استکبار جهانی و ضربات ناجوانمردانهٔ آنان از ابتدای تشکیل نظام جمهوری اسلامی تا کنون، کسانی که در زندانهای سراسر کشور بر سر موضع نفاق خود پافشاری کرده و میکنند، محارب و محکوم به اعدام میباشند.» (رضایی و سلیمی نمین، پاسداشت حقیقت:147)


[9]


Translation:


"Since:


1. PMOI members do not believe in Islam, while pretending otherwise.


2. Due to their systematic military war in the northern, western and southern Iranian borders ...


3. Due to their cooperation with Saddam Hussein in war against Iran ...


4. Due to spying against Iran ...


5. Due to their connections with Western powers ([acting against Iran's independence]) ...


all those jailed PMOI members who continue supporting PMOI and its positions are considered militant enemies and need to be executed."



Quote:One of the consequences of the killings was the resignation of Grand Ayatollah Hossein-Ali Montazeri as the heir-designate to Ayatollah Khomeini as Supreme Leader of Iran.

WRONG! Montazeri was dismissed by Khomeini, there was no resignation. THis is a famous incident in which khomeini wrote to parliament dismissing Montazeri as his successor.


There are many many many more inaccuracies in the article, I cant deal with them all since I have better things to do. Alll im saying JohnDoe is your understanding of history is very shallow and sensational. Admit it.

Reply
#16

Nope Im not denying there were executions numbering in the thousands. But if you understood the circumustances of the time you can completely understand why it happened.


Non-muslims were never forced to flee their homes, thats just another figment of your imagination.

Reply
#17

Bismillahl


Suhail, just wanted to express appreciation to your new sig. Mash a Allah excellent.


Peace and prayer be upon our beloved teacher, leader, role model, the best of mankind and final Messenger Mohamed Ibn Abdullah, his household, companions and all other prophets and messengers.

Reply
#18

Quote:Bismillahl
Suhail, just wanted to express appreciation to your new sig. Mash a Allah excellent.


Peace and prayer be upon our beloved teacher, leader, role model, the best of mankind and final Messenger Mohamed Ibn Abdullah, his household, companions and all other prophets and messengers.

Thank You Muslimah


Please also make dua that i pass my exams and inshallah that i gradute in June.

Reply
#19

Bismillah


Insh a Allah Suhail, may Allah Bring your effort to a success and makes it useful knowledge to you ameen. May Allah Allows you to retain all what you learn and Brings it back to you whenever you need it ameen.


Wow I still remember when we first met here on the board, Insh a Allah graduating in June. Ooo Sobhan Allah time really flies I wish I could attend the graduation ceremony, this will be a very speical day for me Suhail really it will be.

Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 6 Guest(s)