Question On Iraq, Killing, Etc

[Megadeth]

In regards to the 47 people trying to make a living in Iraq who were killed today by a car bomb; In what way do the people who kill these other Muslims hope to gain?


Who gave these Muslims the right to decide who lives and who dies?


If one Muslim killing another is the work of Allah then an American who kills a Muslim must be the work of Allah right?


Or is this all just Allah's work when a Muslim kills another person and Satan's work when a non-Muslim kills somebody?

[lifutushi]

If one Muslim killing another is the work of Allah then an American who kills a Muslim must be the work of Allah right?
Or is this all just Allah's work when a Muslim kills another person and Satan's work when a non-Muslim kills somebody?

it's human work......

[Megadeth]

I agree with that.


So are you saying it's right or it's wrong?


Thanks.

[lifutushi]

wrong

[Megadeth]

Thanks. Just wanted to make sure.

[Rock]

It is a satan`s work when you come to my home and kill me.


It is Allha`s work when I defend myself and kill you.


This is the justice, what ever who is moslem and who in non-moslem.


So the palastinean and the iraqe have the right to defend themselves.

[lifutushi]

it's a satan work to ask you to kill someone innocent... but the killing is your work...


it's Allah's work to ask you to defend your country... but the defending is your work..


i don't condemn when an occupation army was killed in Iraq....


i also won't condemn when an Israeli soldier was killed in Palestine...


but when it came to civilians, be it muslims or not - killers and victims - that should be condemned...

[Rock]

God bless you brother Lifutushi


I ask you to refer to Holly Quran 8/17 , 28/15 ,38/82-83


I want and you want,even the satan wants but the God do what he wants.


So it is simple that when we say (Allha`s work)we mean that we try to


do what the God wants us to do,and when we say (satan`s work)we mean


that we try to do what the satans urge us to do.


I hope I can explain what I mean well.

[lifutushi]

ok, i got your point....thank you..

[Megadeth]

It is a satan`s work when you come to my home and kill me.
It is Allha`s work when I defend myself and kill you.


This is the justice, what ever who is moslem and who in non-moslem.


So the palastinean and the iraqe have the right to defend themselves.

ROCK, Thank you so much for supporting the UNITED STATES of AMERICA!


This is what I was looking for. By your own words this means that you think the people who attacked the United States on 9/11 were doing Satan's work. According to you

It is a satan`s work when you come to my home and kill me.

Now that you've cleared that up tell me who defends the innocent people? When that bomb goes off on a bus to kill people randomly who's work is that according to you? I can understand lifutushi's stance, even though I think he thinks that the US helping Iraq to become a modern country free of a ruler like Saddam was a bad thing, I can respect his opinion.


Also, I'd like to know if you think that any of the people like Al Sadr may be doing fighting the new Iraqi government for their own political aspirations? Or does not happen with Muslims? (see Saddam Hussein for reference)